← Back to show

Archived forum thread

ETS Tour Journal

2007/02/23 - Lille, France [Zenith]

23 Posts
2007-02-23 Show date
Le Zénith Venue
Master of the Ninth Arch
2007/02/23 - Lille, France [Zenith]
Setlist (I think):

New flesh + pinion (recorded)
Love is not enough
Sin
Terrible lie
March of the Pigs
Closer/only time
The Line Begins To Blur
Reptile
No You Don't
Burn
Hmiaih-Eraser
Gave up
Survivalism
La mer / Into the void (tambourine featured :D)
Wish
Suck
Hurt
The Hand that Feeds
HLAH

Not sure about the order, but this was tonights setlist
Master of the Ninth Arch
During Help me I Am in Hell, the 2 guys with strobe lights were awesome. The lighting is really cool on this mini-tour.

The Popo REALLY Blows. They played 15 minutes, and it were the worst 15 of my life. Sound was really crappy too, must be because of their shitty gear.

Not to many people were attending this show. Floor wasn't full, balcony was though. No guitar smashing during HLAH (Aaron had a scothblond telecaster).

Trent was really happy about playing Lille the first time. He said if he had known he'd start playing there sooner.

I got myself a red flyer (they were just laying there next to the tshirt stands), got myself an 'I am trying to believe' tshirt and a black NIN logo poster (3€ w00t).

Great night.NIN is badass live, they rock.
you forgot "down in it" in your setlist
it was played at the middle of the show
one of the best live act i've ever seen
hope they come back soon
we posted the plaulist before the show... not here of course

1pinion
2love is not enough
3sin
4terrible lie
5march of the pigs
6the line begins to blur
7closer
8reptile
9burn
10no you don't
11give up
12help me i'm in hell
13eraser
14la mer+into the void
15survivalism
16wish
17suck
18down in it
19hurt
20the hand that feeds
21head like a hole
Master of the Ninth Arch
spud59 wrote:you forgot "down in it" in your setlist
it was played at the middle of the show
one of the best live act i've ever seen
hope they come back soon
oops. Was a little tired last night, so I forgot.
They played one of the phone messages during the survivalism breakdown.
Knight of the Royal Axe
Spectrious wrote:
spud59 wrote:you forgot "down in it" in your setlist
it was played at the middle of the show
one of the best live act i've ever seen
hope they come back soon
oops. Was a little tired last night, so I forgot.
They played one of the phone messages during the survivalism breakdown.
Oh cool, do you remember which one it was? Damnit... I'm getting more anxious for a show in the states now...
Master of the Ninth Arch
Domewhat_Samaged wrote:
Spectrious wrote:
spud59 wrote:you forgot "down in it" in your setlist
it was played at the middle of the show
one of the best live act i've ever seen
hope they come back soon
oops. Was a little tired last night, so I forgot.
They played one of the phone messages during the survivalism breakdown.
Oh cool, do you remember which one it was? Damnit... I'm getting more anxious for a show in the states now...
It was a woman's voice, think it was the colombian one, but don't shoot me if I'm wrong.
Incredible show! Trent and the guys were top notch, highly energetic. Trent's voice was perfect. The sound was very good as you could hear the instruments mix crystal clear.
I never knew NIN could fill the Zenith in here, apparentely neither did they as Trent said "if I had known you people would be here, we would have come sooner, thank you".

Highlights for me were Terrible Lie, Down in it, Into the Void (Oh God that bass!!!), and Hurt (you just cannot resist to this, chills...)

Happy we got Reptile, Burn, Down in it and Into the void, but no SICNH, no Frail/Wretched, no Only...

Anyway, best NIN show I've ever experienced.
Bricklayer
Spectrious wrote:
Domewhat_Samaged wrote:
Spectrious wrote:
spud59 wrote:you forgot "down in it" in your setlist
it was played at the middle of the show
one of the best live act i've ever seen
hope they come back soon
oops. Was a little tired last night, so I forgot.
They played one of the phone messages during the survivalism breakdown.
Oh cool, do you remember which one it was? Damnit... I'm getting more anxious for a show in the states now...
It was a woman's voice, think it was the colombian one, but don't shoot me if I'm wrong.
No, it was the USWiretap file. I clearly heard the final "Mia ! Mia !". One hell of a show, that's for sure !
Movies or Pictures about this show ?


This concert its very amazing, so funny :D

(sorry for my english, I'm french)
What about All the pigs, all lined up?

I really liked the concert :-)
It was my fisrt NIN show and an amazing show, very energic, perfect setlist even if we got no Last, no Mr Self-Destruct and no Ruiner, The Popo was funny and i'm sure that only open-minded people liked them.
I took some videos from the crowd but they're not in great quality, i'll upload them soon.
So, anyone has audio or videos of the show, the only decent video i got is in my brain :)

P.S. : sorry for the english, i'm french.
Bricklayer
Thanks streichholz for the pictures.

Come on French pigs ! Only 12 reviews... i can't believe it. This show deserves more.

Well, it was my fith NIN show on the With Teeth Live Tour and this one was... good, just good. The setlist was not exceptionnal : no last, no ruiner, no the becoming, no the frail-the wretched, no somethig i can never have.

What I prefered during the show : help me i am in hell - eraser - la mer - into the void... ambient & atmospheric... very moody... undoubtedly the highlight of the setlist.

The intro (the one on the AATCHB dvd) and pinion were excellent...

Reptile was excellent too. Trent was really in with an agressive look in the eye.

Down in it : i am glad to have heard it once live. This song may have more than 15 years but it still rocks !

The bad points now : love is not enough is not a good song to start with... survivalism borred me a lot... Jeordie and Alessandro were invisible (sorry men). The energy of the show came from Trent & Aaron only (thanks men).

Well, i have to say tha some (i said some, not the whole) of the french audience sucks... people with zero energy just in front of the stage... people who talk during la mer (i am not the man who shout "Vos gueules")... people who don't know NIN songs... and so on...

Feel free to post your vision of the show.

Cheers.

Blin.
Master Traveler
The show was very compact. No you Don't really blew the Zenith's roof, my god I can't quite recall hearing stg so powerful!!! Reptile was very heavy too. La Mer and Into the void were tremendous, Burn was excellent as well (although I usually do not like it). Survivalism sounds A LOT better live.

Nice list. I'm very happy (although we didn't get any surprise song).

I'm quite sure that some of the music that was played before the shows is somehow linked to the Year Zero thingy (I'm not saying songs). One slightly reminded me of the trailer on the Yearzero website, but that is just my feeling. Swans and TV on the Radio songs were played too.

The Popo were good fun and got a lot better when they switched instruments. Shame they had problems with one of the synths. Aaron joined them for one song (as previuosly stated)

Smoking machines were tested (a lot), The new Flesh was launched with lights still on, the roadies were patiently holding guitars (a bit like Her Majesty's private guard), Lights went down on Pinion and they took to the stage with 'Love is not enough'.

It was good to hear 'Down in It' as well (good old memories) and I was a tiny bit disappointed by 'The Line Begins To Blur' which I usually really like live (I had the feeling that Alessandro's keyboards were too low in the beginning of the show).

People in Lille were really nice and easy going (yeah, there were a couple of morons but you find them everywhere…).

All in all a very good evening. I met very nice people
The concert was awesome, the band had an excellent performance. I’ve watched a lot of NIN dvd concerts, and this was my frist NIN live concert, and it was too beautiful to be true. I arrived late, the floor was almost empty and most of the French audience seemed to be everything but NIN fans. Upstairs was full (weird), and the people downstairs seemed quiet boring during the concert (when the band was done the public didn’t ask for more, nobody, and NIN just finished their great concert).
Blin says that just Trent and Aaron were really visible, but I don’t know where Blin was. I was at the second row and it was pretty cool to have Trent and Jeordie just in front of me. The band really has energy. They made just a little pause in the middle. Watching NIN live is a wonderful experience. Trent’s voice seemed to be scratching our hearts, expressing the scream of dispair that we all know from his studio albums.
The AATCHB intro was really good, and in my opinion Love is not enough is a great song as intro. I was glad to hear Closer, Burn, and Gave up live, but I thought The hand that feeds was going to sound better live, which it wasn’t the case.
It’s true that the French audience was boring, and in the very front weren’t slamming each other, some were already very stoned and had to be removed by the security guards. Me and my friend sang all the lyrics, some people too, but I had the impression that most of the people came to the show just because they had money and time to do something fun during the weekend, or by curiosity.
Trent said during the show that NIN would keep on tour forever, so I’ll remember this kick ass concert!!
Common NIN fans!! The intro wasn't Pinion, and this song wasn't never played during this concert. The intro was the one of the And all that could have been DVD. The concert was pretty gnarly!! I'm looking forward they come to The Netherlands soon to see them again!!
Peanut gallery
Meneertje wrote:The intro wasn't Pinion, and this song wasn't never played during this concert.
They played a quite long version of A New Flesh which lead into Pinion for a short while.
Master Traveler
h6a6t6e wrote:
Meneertje wrote:The intro wasn't Pinion, and this song wasn't never played during this concert.
They played a quite long version of A New Flesh which lead into Pinion for a short while.
I confirm most of the intro was The new Flesh and a small bit of Pinion in the end
Great show, much better than the Eurocks 2005 one. Less blinding lights, which only can be a good. The only "weak" point : "Love is not enough" is not a really satisfying intro song, but Sin made me accept to apologize the band for that disappointing thing.

I also noticed the fact Trent seems not to like to annoy, kick and eventually fight a it with his musicians anymore. Maybe also helps to make NIN looks like a band on stage and not just "Reznor and his musicians".
Peanut gallery
Apparently audio has been released, anyone know where?
Bricklayer
Yes, it's been released on www.dimeadozen.org

The audio quality seems pretty good... I want to hear the combo "help me, i am in hell - eraser - la mer - into the void" again...

Cheers.