Archived forum thread
ETS Tour Journal
2007/03/15 - Dortmund, GER [Westfallenhalle2]
Bricklayer
it's always interesting when videos are up on youtube of the show before anyone has a word to say about it..
apologize for breaking the rules.
apologize for breaking the rules.
Bricklayer
I went to it, and it was absolutly amazing. This was my second NIN concert and I enjoyed it much more then my first. THe crowd was awsome, and I was near the front. Mosh was awsome. Only song off Year Zero was Survivalism and the Mosh was crazy during it! LadyTron was way better then it was on album.
Grand Pontiff
Setlist?
Bricklayer
Totally different set than yesterday in cologne. Many songs from "Pretty Hate Machine" and "The Fragile". I am not going to try to list the songs in their correct order because I know that I am going to mess it up.
Master Traveler
yeah well how about a rough guess?zappy wrote:Totally different set than yesterday in cologne. Many songs from "Pretty Hate Machine" and "The Fragile". I am not going to try to list the songs in their correct order because I know that I am going to mess it up.
Or just list the songs you can remember in chronological order?
at least let us know so we can feel jelous :p
Bricklayer
They definetly went from the intro bit of "la mer" seamlessly into "into the void", which was a highlight. Don't ask me for the rest, since I'm still completely exhausted.
Bricklayer
ok, this is not in chronological order, but rather by album, so here goes:
Head like a hole
Terrible lie
Down in it
Something I can never have
Sin
Pinion
Wish
Help me I'm in hell
Gave up
Suck
March of the pigs
Closer
Hurt
The frail/The wretched
No you don't
La mer
Into the void
Love is not enough
The hand that feeds
Survivalism
Burn
I think that's all. Please correct me if I forgot something.
Head like a hole
Terrible lie
Down in it
Something I can never have
Sin
Pinion
Wish
Help me I'm in hell
Gave up
Suck
March of the pigs
Closer
Hurt
The frail/The wretched
No you don't
La mer
Into the void
Love is not enough
The hand that feeds
Survivalism
Burn
I think that's all. Please correct me if I forgot something.
Bricklayer
To review: this was my second NIN gig also, and the first one was way better. The band was in top form yesterday though, but the audience spoiled it for me. Maybe it was just the spot that I was in, but the crowd was totally lame, just standing there with crossed arms, noone even dancing. Damn, I had a meter of space right in front of me. In Berlin 2005, I could have put up my feet and not fallen down. I could see a mosh pit in the first five rows or something, but that was all. And they totally blew the sing-along part of March of the Pigs. Well, as I said, the band was tops though. Trent's speech right before Survivalism seems to become a regular.
Oh, and Ladytron were better than I expected from reading the threads here. Quite likable in fact.
Oh, and Ladytron were better than I expected from reading the threads here. Quite likable in fact.
Bricklayer
You forgot eraser and only.
Compared to the audience in Cologne on wednesday, the audience was definitely pretty lame and silent. On the other hand the location was wider than in Cologne, might have been a reason as well. And in Cologne it was impossible, NOT to dance and freak out from the first second.
It was great to see NIN twice in two days with two different setlists.
It was great to see NIN twice in two days with two different setlists.
Bricklayer
The niggy tardust-remix of survivalism was actually played before the show. Sounded slightly R&B-ish and slower than the original-version.
Master Traveler
23 songs + intro? Fuckin WOW :O
Bricklayer
Eraser, yes. Only? Uh, nope.shhhh wrote:You forgot eraser and only.
YeahCloser wrote:23 songs + intro? Fuckin WOW :O
Well, Pinion _was_ the intro, HMIAIH was kind of an intro for Eraser, IIRC, La Mer was the intro for Into the Void, and The Frail was the intro for the Wretched. I believe they played a total of 90 minutes or so.
Bricklayer
Wow... I got there after the doors opened and everybody was buying drinks and no one was near the staged, I was about 4-5 meters from Trent and I only went in about 30 minutes before LadyTron started.The mosh was definatly no metal band mosh, but was bigger then last time I saw NIN, and where I was the crowd was crazy. I was the really short guy wearing a black NIn shirt.antares wrote:To review: this was my second NIN gig also, and the first one was way better. The band was in top form yesterday though, but the audience spoiled it for me. Maybe it was just the spot that I was in, but the crowd was totally lame, just standing there with crossed arms, noone even dancing. Damn, I had a meter of space right in front of me. In Berlin 2005, I could have put up my feet and not fallen down. I could see a mosh pit in the first five rows or something, but that was all. And they totally blew the sing-along part of March of the Pigs. Well, as I said, the band was tops though. Trent's speech right before Survivalism seems to become a regular.
Oh, and Ladytron were better than I expected from reading the threads here. Quite likable in fact.
Bricklayer
I tried to remember the setlist when I was home, but so tired that everything got blurry. Pinion was intro and I think 'Love Is Not Enough, Sin(God, my favsong!) and March of the Pigs' were next. Then...NOT IN ORDER:
Terrible Lie
Something I Can Never Have
The Wretched
Closer
Help me I'm in hell
Down in it
Wish
Into the void
No, you dont
Survivalism
Gave up
Eraser
Suck
Hurt
One thing's for sure, the show concluded with Hand That Feeds and Head Like A Hole. Heh.
I was at the middle of the front, so didn't know the crowd was lame or not. Yeah, some girl in front of me only took pictures. That was annoying. Though I was very impressived by the perfomance cause NIN hasn't visited my country Korea yet. I do love Germany. There's many chances hier to see such a great show. NIN rocks! It would be better, if I had had the tambourine XD
Terrible Lie
Something I Can Never Have
The Wretched
Closer
Help me I'm in hell
Down in it
Wish
Into the void
No, you dont
Survivalism
Gave up
Eraser
Suck
Hurt
One thing's for sure, the show concluded with Hand That Feeds and Head Like A Hole. Heh.
I was at the middle of the front, so didn't know the crowd was lame or not. Yeah, some girl in front of me only took pictures. That was annoying. Though I was very impressived by the perfomance cause NIN hasn't visited my country Korea yet. I do love Germany. There's many chances hier to see such a great show. NIN rocks! It would be better, if I had had the tambourine XD
Bricklayer
I uploaded my Dortmund videos:
Something I can never have
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=MYAT399B
Wish
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=7CJ39BQJ
Eraser
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=R2JJM0IC
No you don´t
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=X144JGXF
Hurt
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=RG541QUA
And I´m gonna post some pix soon.
Something I can never have
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=MYAT399B
Wish
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=7CJ39BQJ
Eraser
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=R2JJM0IC
No you don´t
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=X144JGXF
Hurt
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=RG541QUA
And I´m gonna post some pix soon.
Bricklayer
holy fucking what camera is that?_rebekka_ wrote:I uploaded my Dortmund videos:
Something I can never have
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=MYAT399B
Wish
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=7CJ39BQJ
Eraser
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=R2JJM0IC
No you don´t
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=X144JGXF
Hurt
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=RG541QUA
And I´m gonna post some pix soon.
Grand Pontiff
amazing videos , but are those green flashes when the strobe lights flicker part of the light show or the camera screwing up, either way it looks sick and kinda bugs my eyes out_rebekka_ wrote:I uploaded my Dortmund videos:
Something I can never have
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=MYAT399B
Wish
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=7CJ39BQJ
Eraser
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=R2JJM0IC
No you don´t
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=X144JGXF
Hurt
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=RG541QUA
And I´m gonna post some pix soon.
Master of the Ninth Arch
I think it may be the camera. I get that too, and I think it could give me a seizure after a while. Fantastic videos none the less.DaveMuzik85 wrote:amazing videos , but are those green flashes when the strobe lights flicker part of the light show or the camera screwing up, either way it looks sick and kinda bugs my eyes out
Bricklayer
did you notice that during Something I Can Never Have, shortly after the 2nd minute, Trent say something..murmles actually..do you know what it might have been?
Prince Adept
For real.bknollenberg wrote:holy fucking what camera is that?_rebekka_ wrote:I uploaded my Dortmund videos:
Something I can never have
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=MYAT399B
Wish
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=7CJ39BQJ
Eraser
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=R2JJM0IC
No you don´t
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=X144JGXF
Hurt
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=RG541QUA
And I´m gonna post some pix soon.
Bricklayer
The show wold have been perfect if it had, Great Below, Only, Big Comedown, and StarFuckers. Still awsome though
Bricklayer
It´s a Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ7Clocksrun wrote:For real.bknollenberg wrote:holy fucking what camera is that?_rebekka_ wrote:I uploaded my Dortmund videos:
Something I can never have
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=MYAT399B
Wish
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=7CJ39BQJ
Eraser
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=R2JJM0IC
No you don´t
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=X144JGXF
Hurt
http://www.megaupload.com/de/?d=RG541QUA
And I´m gonna post some pix soon.
Bricklayer
Does someone know the guy in the audience who could have been Trent Reznors double? Small, short black hair, wearing a olive green parka with a marilyn manson sticker on one arm. I did talk to him before the concert and he mentioned to be from Dortmund but I forgot to ask for any kind of address. He was also at the concert in Cologne. A message would be nice. Thanks!
yeah! I was waiting for a long long time for nin to come! and finally they were standing on stage. the concert was like magic, just perfect! the sound and the show were a lot better than in cologne. and I´m the lucky one who got trents tambourine. thank you, trent
. still not able to believe...hope nin will come back here. I´m always ready to rock again!!
Bricklayer
hey man, I was right in front of you at one time. I'm the little dude.me wrote:yeah! I was waiting for a long long time for nin to come! and finally they were standing on stage. the concert was like magic, just perfect! the sound and the show were a lot better than in cologne. and I´m the lucky one who got trents tambourine. thank you, trent. still not able to believe...hope nin will come back here. I´m always ready to rock again!!
I'm not got a tambourine, but trent smashed a bottle water in my face. that's great too, isn't it? Pain...me wrote:yeah! I was waiting for a long long time for nin to come! and finally they were standing on stage. the concert was like magic, just perfect! the sound and the show were a lot better than in cologne. and I´m the lucky one who got trents tambourine. thank you, trent. still not able to believe...hope nin will come back here. I´m always ready to rock again!!
the bottle (without water):

Bricklayer
Still prettyc ool, I'd rather the tambourine though...annika wrote:I'm not got a tambourine, but trent smashed a bottle water in my face. that's great too, isn't it? Pain...me wrote:yeah! I was waiting for a long long time for nin to come! and finally they were standing on stage. the concert was like magic, just perfect! the sound and the show were a lot better than in cologne. and I´m the lucky one who got trents tambourine. thank you, trent. still not able to believe...hope nin will come back here. I´m always ready to rock again!!
the bottle (without water):
no one has the exact Setlist?
how come fuckhead, you could have got the tambourine, when i got it, too??? shut the fuck up, whats wrong with you?me wrote:yeah! I was waiting for a long long time for nin to come! and finally they were standing on stage. the concert was like magic, just perfect! the sound and the show were a lot better than in cologne. and I´m the lucky one who got trents tambourine. thank you, trent. still not able to believe...hope nin will come back here. I´m always ready to rock again!!
BTW I goit one of Joshs stix, too. I was the lucky guy that night *G*
@antares
people like you should stay at home, cause you were one of the ones standing around, werent you? shit on yourself, i had fun freaking out dancing all the precious time. It was awesome. I was at the first show at Brixton the week before, too and I have to say this performance in dortmund was much better. (but still I have to mention düsseldorf - fragility tour was still the best, Ive seen)
Where I was standing people were very kind, had lots of fun and definitely it was all one and I believe the band could feel it , too, that part of why they had fun, too. Brixton was more like a melting pot with all kinds of people in the crowd, puzzle parts that didnt fit and Trent still had a hard time with his voice. Nevertheless, Brixton Academy is the more impressive venue and besides I didnt see or hear people talking shit about standing around or fake plastic dreams of tambourines.
I tried to recontruct the setlist, but it seems I cant make the pieces fit no more, please correct me in the middle part, its all messed up in my head, so what?!:
Pinion
Love is not enough
Sin
March of the Pigs
The frail/The wretched
Burn
Suck
Closer
Something I can never have
Help me I'm in hell/Eraser
Wish
Down in it
Survivalism
Hurt
La mer/Into the void
Gave up
Terrible lie
No you don't
the Hand that Feeds
Head like a hole
.....throw your handys in the air......
^ are you sure,
that sin was the third song?°°
i thought it was teribble lie..
hm..
I know that there were some people who have made notes (of the setlist),
one of them stand in front of me.
that sin was the third song?°°
i thought it was teribble lie..
hm..
I know that there were some people who have made notes (of the setlist),
one of them stand in front of me.
no, Im not so sure, the line begins to blur *G* I just remember that the 3rd song was from PHM. First I thought of terrible lie, too because I definitely know I heard it somewhere But someone here mentioned s/he was sure it was SIN, so I thought I might be wrong and put it in third place. I might be wrong...Gast wrote:^ are you sure,
that sin was the third song?°°
i thought it was teribble lie..
hm..
I know that there were some people who have made notes (of the setlist),
one of them stand in front of me.
now again, when i think about it, down in it was somewhat one of the last songs and burn came after SICNH, didnt it:
Pinion
Love is not enough
???Sin OR terrible lie???
March of the Pigs
???
The frail/the wretched
Suck
Closer
Something I can never have
Burn
Help me I'm in hell/Eraser
Wish
Survivalism
Hurt
La mer/Into the void
Gave up
No you don't
Down in it
???
the Hand that Feeds
Head like a hole
Pinion
Love is not enough
???Sin OR terrible lie???
March of the Pigs
???
The frail/the wretched
Suck
Closer
Something I can never have
Burn
Help me I'm in hell/Eraser
Wish
Survivalism
Hurt
La mer/Into the void
Gave up
No you don't
Down in it
???
the Hand that Feeds
Head like a hole
I was pretty much in the front row and I took notes of the set list because I wanted to make an iTunes playlist mirroring the show. This is my version. I'm almost 100 percent certain this is correct.
Pinion (as intro)
Love is Not Enough
Sin
Terrible Lie
March of the pigs
Something I Can Never Have
The Frail
The Wretched
Closer
Burn
No, You Don't
Gave Up
Help Me I am in Hell
Eraser
La Mer
Into the Void
Wish
Survivalism
Suck
Down in It
Hurt
The Hand that Feeds
Head Like a Hole
I wanted to hear a lot more of Year Zero. Guess we'll have to wait until April.
Pinion (as intro)
Love is Not Enough
Sin
Terrible Lie
March of the pigs
Something I Can Never Have
The Frail
The Wretched
Closer
Burn
No, You Don't
Gave Up
Help Me I am in Hell
Eraser
La Mer
Into the Void
Wish
Survivalism
Suck
Down in It
Hurt
The Hand that Feeds
Head Like a Hole
I wanted to hear a lot more of Year Zero. Guess we'll have to wait until April.
thank you very much, noteguy 
i hope you weren't the short guy with beard..
i hope you weren't the short guy with beard..
Why? What did the short hairy guy do?
nothing.noteguy wrote:Why? What did the short hairy guy do?
Bricklayer
My mum uploaded some photos on her Deviantart Account.
Bricklayer
noteguy has it right I'm pretty sure, and did anyone see an uber high guy trying to mosh to something I can never have, he was fucking annoying! and are we talking about the short guy with the beard wearing a green shirt? he was cool if so. and I could of sworn trent through 2 tambourines. one was caught right next to me, and I could of sworn he also threw one to a girl at the very front... could just be me though
Thanks a lotulrike wrote:My mum uploaded some photos on her Deviantart Account.








